10 Habits of Happy Mothers: More on Refusing to Compete or Compare

Last time, we took a first look at competing and comparing and how we hurt ourselves by engaging in competitive tussles with other mothers. In the combox, Natalia made an important distinction:

Does comparison equal competition?
I struggled with this chapter because I felt I couldn't relate. Not because I don't compare myself to others, but because I don't feel that I compete. I wonder if it IS an American thing.( I always say that the reason why the Dominican Republic doesn't win anything in the Olympics is that we don't take things seriously enough. No baseball or soccer moms there!)
Anyhow, whether you call it competition or comparison, comparisons are deadly. When we compare, we always come out a loser. What a waste of precious energy! And what a missed opportunity to see, really see, what the Lord is doing in our own lives!
I don't want to sound as if I don't struggle with this. I struggle with envy. I see others and wish I had the talents they have, the house they have, the admiration they have. But I don't feel is a competition. I don't want to be better than they. I just want what they have, does that make sense?

I think her point makes perfect sense! And I also think it's an important distinction. When we compare, we often beat ourselves up and hold ourselves in contempt for not being what we perceive other people to be or having what we think they have. I think most of the damage done with comparing is done internally; we do it to ourselves.

When we compete, it often (always?) begins as a comparison, but we extend it and we try to be better (smarter, more organized, more efficient, thinner, prettier, more accomplished) than the person to whom we compare ourselves. We don't leave the thought at wishing we could have or be what they have; we want more than they have. We wrestle for position in our own eyes and the eyes of others. Dr. Meeker writes, "As moms we compete in two arenas, we have our lives as well as the lives of our kids to watch out for. Sometimes jealousy takes such a strong hold on us that we have difficulty having any good relationships with other mothers.  When we are jealous of other mothers because they seem to have life perfectly balanced or figured out, we find ourselves wanting to be with them and hating to be near them, all at the same time. We want to see how they do it, but since we feel that we can’t do what they do or have what they have, we leave angrier than ever. We always feel so inadequate or guilty when we are with them that we just scrap the whole friendship thing altogether."

I've seen this go very wrong. It begins as a friendship and there is some degree of mutual trust. Two women let each other into one another's intimate thoughts and hearts.  And then one or both of them begin to try to prove to the other (and to other people) that she is superior. Maybe it's really just that she's trying to prove it to herself. In the comparing and the competing, she tears the other woman down. She pounces on flaws–real or imagined-and exposes them. She relishes for a fleeting moment in feeling superior. But then she is left alone and lonely. The people around her are likely to recognize what happened and to steer clear. Who wants a friends who tears down the other women in her life? The friend she harmed establishes a firm boundary and holds her at a safe distance. In the end, she is left with bitterness. And not much else.

There are several ways the author suggests that we overcome competition. Before we put them into action, though, we have to discern that we don't want to compete. We have to believe that mothers and friends are better off if they cooperate. You can't hold on to competition with one hand and try to cooperate with the other. It doesn't work. And competition, fueled by inevitable anger, will win. Why do you want to compete? What will it gain you? If you have everything that other woman has and you succeed in besting her, where does that leave you? Is it really a better place?

Dr. Meeker suggests, among other things, that women focus on fullness instead of emptiness. This echoes the urgent call to gratitude so many women have heard and answered this year. Gratitude works. It blesses in friendships as in every other realm of our lives as women. When we focus on the fullness of our lives and the blessings other women are to us, we are liberated from the bondage of competition. 

In addition to gazing on what we have and intentionally giving thanks for it, Dr. Meeker challenges us to be kind. The habit of kindness and the power it has to bring about miracles in our lives is a favorite topic of mine. Dr. Meeker reminds us that,  Being kind to loved ones is easy, and it makes us feel good because when they are happier, we feel happier. Helping good friends and loved ones can be a bit self-serving because we usually reap great rewards for our kindness toward them. Either we directly benefit from it, or they return the favor. But the real test comes when we reach out on behalf of those we don’t really like. And most often we don’t really like the mothers whom we’re really jealous of. So if we want to get rid  of our jealousy, the best way to shovel out the rot of the feelings is to find something very nice to do for the other mother

I'm not sure that my experience bears out mothers not really liking the one whom who inspires feelings of jealousy or inferiority in their lives. I think it's very possible to want what a good friend has. The divergence comes in what happens next. If we are truly good friends, we don't tear her down in an effort to get it, even though we wish we had it. Instead, we are genuinely glad on her behalf. This is the point Natalia was making. All comparison isn't competition. I think comparing often leads us to feeling badly about ourselves. Competing invariably hurts both ourselves and the other woman. 

Regardless of the distinction, kindness is a good antidote both comparing and competing. Many a friendship, long, loyal, and self-sacrificing, rested at first on no thicker a foundation than a kind word. We can cultivate a habit of kind listening, where once we were mentally comparing and one-upping and planning the destruction (even a little) of the woman speaking. We can stretch to forgive and excuse and understand others, offering the genuine warmth of Christian charity. In behaving this way, we find ourselves shining the best light on our friends, rather than tearing them down. A corollary here is refusing to engage in gossip. Ever. Even if it costs the friendship if the third party, we can't allow ourselves to gossip about a mutual friend. Good friends don't do that. Happy mothers don't do that. Gossip invariably dissolves in bitter misery. 

Speaking of friends, my dear friend just walked in. And since this "laptop" is hogging all the table space, it's time to put it away and have lunch with a woman who has stood shoulder-to shoulder with me in the mommyhood since our big girls were not yet school-aged. I'm counting my blessings and she's on the list.

How about you?


{{This post is the 8th in a series discussing The 10 Habits of Happy Mothers: Reclaiming our Passion, Purpose, and Sanity.}}

The rest of our discussions of  The 10 Habits of Happy Mothers: Reclaiming our Passion, Purpose, and Sanity can be found here. The first two conversations are 

Part 1(discussing Habit 1)

Part 2 (still discussing Habit 1)

Part 3 (still more on Habit 1)

Part 4 (Habit 2: key friendships)

Part 5 (Habit 2: your thoughts on friendship_

Part 6 (Habit 3: Value and Practice Faith)

Part 7(Habit 4: Say No to Competition)



  1. says

    I find I have trouble in the blogging and homeschool realm. I find I don’t quite fit in anywhere…I work part-time, my three oldest went to regular school, I have issues with my oldest son and teenage daughter, as well as struggling with depression myself. I am dealing with loss of fertility due to age and lost three pregnancies after my 7 yr. old was born. So… there’s this *I wish had that kind of life* echo inside. I know that everyone has their crosses to carry and no life is without pain, but there is a sort of longing…the *I wish* pattern…*I wish* I could have more children…*I wish* I could live somewhere rural in the country…*I wish* I could be home full time…*I wish* my older children were raised differently. It is toxic. I am trying my best to keep a gratitude journal and have been faithful…but I guess with depression, some days it just isn’t enough. Once in a while, I have to step back from blogging since I DO compare…it’s not wrong to aspire to be a better person but when envy creeps in…that is dangerous. Thanks, Elizabeth, for posting a topic that has been weighing heavily on me.

  2. Michelle says

    I think it’s important to make the distinction between jealousy and envy. Correct me if I’m wrong, but from my understanding, Dr. Meeker is not using the right word when she chooses jealousy. Jealousy is when we want something someone else has, but in a way we have a right to the object. A woman jealous of another woman because she is flirting with her husband or got a promotion that she lied her way into etc. Jealousy can be justified sometimes. Envy, on the other hand, is when we desire things/qualities others have that we are not entitled to. Another way of putting it is we feel less worthy if we don’t do/act as this other person does. We may even feel upset when something good happens to this person as if it in someway diminishes our self-worth. Envy is never justified. It seems to me that comparisons are not necessarily bad, as Rachel Balducci described in a recent post, we can turn them into inspiration. But, there is also the potential to turn them into envy. It seems Dr. Meeker suggests we do away with comparing all together. I think it’s better to learn, as Rachel said, to turn the comparison into inspiration. If we do away with comparing, than no one would be reading the lives of the saints, etc.

  3. says

    I can very much relate to what Theresa said in her comment! I am only recently (and I am – shall we say – “mature”) learning to really and truly let go of being competitive. As someone who found academics easy my identity was strongly tied up with being “top of the class.” I am so NOT top of the class when it comes to being a good wife, mother and homemaker – which I now do full time. Thank you, God, for lessons in humility! It was relatively easy to love those who stuggled in my areas of strength, but loving those who make me feel inadequate has required prayer, reflection and growth. I’m getting there, but I do still compare and that can so easily turn from constructive learning to destructive dispair. We need to exercise caution and PRAY.
    One last thing – we shouldn’t neglect to address the impact that this negative behaviour has on our relationships with our children. We compete through them at our peril, of course; but we also harm our relationships with our children when they see us being false, keeping up unrealistic appearances, tearing down others behind their backs, or when we put our fear of what other might think of us ahead of our children’s legitimate desires. That sour face of dissatisfaction is a killer too.

  4. says

    p.s. Can I ask a question? How do you approach this issue with your children as they learn to balance healthy competition, such as in sports, with healthy relationships and self esteem?

  5. says

    I am still having a hard time relating to this. I appreciate the distinction between comparison and competition, but I’m truly having a hard time relating to the competition aspect. As I was reading, I was really trying to look deep and discern honestly if my comparing ever crosses that line into competing. I don’t think it does. I get stuck in the comparing, and feeling bad about myself. More often then not, though, my friendships are able to persevere, I see what I need to work on, and I do. But when there is THAT mom who seems to have ALL the energy in the world, and everything perfecting balanced, and never seems stressed out at all…I do compare myself to her, I feel inadequate, and then I do steer clear of that relationship. I know this is an area I need to work on….but it still doesn’t cross that line to competing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>